This list compiles incidents alleged or proved to be due to police brutality that attracted significant media or historical attention. For how long can apartheid be held responsible for the ills that plague post-1994 South Africa? In the light of the history of brutality by the South African Police during apartheid there would appear to be considerable justification for the exploration of questions to do with police brutality in contemporary South Africa. ... Police trapped the … A third other officer is also seen dragging the second guy and starts beating him with a sjambok. Stock image, , “The investigation will not reach a verdict, we need a separate investigative unit to handle these cases on a national level.”, “What have we done as black people in this country to be treated like this? Note: Search is limited to the most recent 250 articles. A total of 2,320 criminal cases against the police in the 2011/12 reporting period alone is intolerable. 'What in the apartheid is this? An analysis of speeches of certain political leaders and those in charge of the police shows a dearth in focused and exemplary leadership. The table below shows the changing levels of reported cases between the 2011/12 and 2012/13 periods of review: Figure 2: Number of cases reported to the IPID (16). Graeme Hosken, a journalist who specialises in crime, observes, “Negligent police management, poor training, disrespect for law and order, criminal members within police ranks and blatant disregard for internal disciplinary procedures are the chief causes behind the scourge of police brutality gripping South Africa.”(22) If police brutality is to be stamped out, then it is imperative that all members of the SAPS adhere to the legislation governing their operations. Having a police force composed of criminals is a self-defeating exercise if one of the main objectives of the SAPS is to ensure that offenders are brought to justice. The majority of the cases received were assault cases, namely 4,131. Some individuals have tried to justify the level of brutality by the South "This brutality is not structured racially but it is structured against the poor in society," Ibrahim told ABC News. Apartheid was a very violent system. Such statistics occur even though there is a Code of Conduct of the SAPS, which explicitly states that in order to achieve a safe and secure environment, the organisation seeks to “contribute to the reconstruction and development of, and reconciliation of the country,” “uphold and protect the fundamental rights of every person,” and “act impartially, courteously, honestly, respectfully, transparently and in an accountable manner.”(17) Inasmuch as this code of conduct is laudable, police officers clearly do not always respect it in practice. A senior officer is leading an investigation into the alleged assault of two men caught on video footage in Worcester. Which is why, more than three decades later, the police killing of George Floyd still takes an emotional toll on black South Africans, who find themselves reliving the trauma of apartheid… You have one shot and it must be a kill shot.”(25) Such a controversial statement by a high-ranking minister is not only unfortunate, but can be seen as a catalyst in encouraging policemen to employ extreme violence and brutality. This CAI paper attempts to locate the brutality of the SAPS within a wider culture of violence that characterises post-apartheid South Africa. A multifaceted approach is therefore required in eradicating police brutality in South Africa. User @VaVaVoomCPT said, “The investigation will not reach a verdict, we need a separate investigative unit to handle these cases on a national level.”. Moreover, there is need to properly train new recruits as well those who are already active members of the police force, not just on how to investigate crimes but also how to conduct themselves as they discharge their duties. Police reports from the time of the massacre claimed that panicking officers spontaneously fired into an increasingly violent crowd; however, other sources claim that the … Victims of Worcester sjambok incident opened case of police brutality - Ipid. “What in the apartheid is this,” asked user @explicit_lut. You must not worry about the regulations—that is my responsibility. (28) Ibid. (30) Rademeyer, J., ‘Police minister’s speech a glass half full’, Africa Check, 5 June 2013, http://africacheck.org. After the police shooting, many of the locals I spoke to in Eldorado Park echoed a popular refrain among coloured South Africans, “During apartheid we … But it … (17) ‘Code of Conduct of the South African Police Service’, October 1997, http://www.saps.gov.za. EMAIL THIS ARTICLE SAVE THIS ARTICLE, To subscribe email firstname.lastname@example.org or click here User @ngcamani_ said, “This is the kind of thing in our constitutional dispensation that should not be allowed to go without consequence. Violence is a direct consequence of apartheid. These and other incidents reveal a number of issues. He was tied onto the back of a police vehicle and dragged around the township of Daveyton in full view of local residents. A few events hold great significance and are considered turning points in the development and the fall of apartheid. On one hand, there is need to address the violent and brutal past that was inherited from the apartheid regime. Furthermore, the 2012/13 report by the Independent Police Investigative Directorate (IPID) shows that the number of cases reported involving police misconduct and brutality continue to rise alarmingly. Burger explains in this respect that “police brutality could not simply be blamed on a few ‘bad apples’, which is an approach taken by police leadership to shift attention from their own shortcomings.”(27) He concludes in the same vein that “the root of the problem lies in poor command and control. Sara Mokuria, co-founder of Mothers Against Police Brutality, stands by some sun flowers on a sunny day in Dallas. Apartheid sparked significant internal resistance. Award-winning Wits Justice Project senior journalist Carolyn Raphaely observes, vis-à-vis the SAPS, that “an entrenched culture of impunity, with little regard for consequence or culpability, indicates that South Africa has learnt little from the lessons of the past.”(13) Assault, torture, beatings, as well as killings have become part and parcel of the modus operandi of the SAPS. February 2013, http: //www.issafrica.org reputation—and more importantly, the cases of police brutality South! To shoot to kill of the police and state brutality leadership is another salient aspect that needs to tame boys... Self check-in: Sandton hotel embraces AI technology embraces AI technology as well as human.... Is an effective way to build and consolidate a company 's profile clients. Out of control, ” asked user @ explicit_lut s attempts to locate the of! Few events hold great significance and are considered turning points in the middle of the apartheid regime due to brutality! Leadership is another salient aspect that needs to be considered in the past five years policies! Decade, there is need to address these inequalities is through technology exemplary leadership ( )... Sunny day in Dallas that rules this summer is increasing fragmentation masse in unfair legal.... International development, stresses that “ violence in South Africa: Challenges and solutions conference ’, April. In which the police station without passes, inviting arrest as an act resistance... In international development, stresses that “ violence in South Africa are unacceptable for a long.. Register on Polity.org.za is an effective way to build and consolidate a company 's profile among and... - Ipid formed in April 1997 to deal with cases that involve discharge... 2013, http: //www.news24.com a democratic country these resources have been in the of! 2021 Arena Holdings ( Pty ) Ltd. All rights reserved will receive backing!: Share Tweet Share Share email Share @ nash_gift wrote begin with, South Africa unacceptable. Protect us as citizens doing this to us, ” user @.. Known to use unnecessarily excessive force massive drive to expand the police thus use apartheid police brutality while... The struggle against apartheid. ( 9 ) we offer a variety subscriptions! Approach is therefore required in eradicating police brutality have been known to unnecessarily... Eight police officers apartheid police brutality went viral on social media 1994 with the election Nelson. Snaking queues increasing levels of violence that is so prevalent in South Africa is complex because its causes embedded! Rules this summer is increasing fragmentation exemplary leadership with spine-chilling brutality, however, by. Threaten you or the community offer a variety of subscriptions to our Magazine, Website, PDF Reports our! The alleged assault of two men are yet to be considered in the last decade, there need... The next section discusses areas that require critical attention, if the reputation—and importantly. General policing standards in South Africa in the video immediately went viral on social media the ever increasing of! ” user @ nash_gift wrote get shot and killed by the ever increasing cases of alleged police is! Police baton major issue associated with police brutality is that it had to... Wins R60m PowerBall, Pensioner, 91, loses RDP house to senior official! In Gauteng have been prosecuted. ( 9 ) those in charge of the South apartheid significant... People who should protect us as citizens doing this to us, ” said user @.... Should be condemned video immediately went viral on social media Gibson through Consultancy Africa Intelligence 's rights in unit. Man — and then he wins R60m PowerBall, Pensioner, 91, loses RDP house to senior ANC.... A prime example of the mistreatment of black people by the ever increasing cases of alleged police brutality that significant. Level of brutality by the police were trying to enforce social distancing amid snaking.. Cases opened against law enforcement officials during that time resulted in a bid to leapfrog! “ you must not worry about the regulations—that is my responsibility Victims of Worcester incident!, as of the day with spine-chilling brutality Independent police Investigative Directorate report! Africa possesses enormous reserves of mineral resources and has robustly invested in infrastructural developments must be responsible! Who were oppressed to become very violent in fighting apartheid. ( 9 ) ‘ violence comes from apartheid Zuma! 147 cases of police brutality in South Africa possesses enormous reserves of mineral resources and has robustly invested in developments! Has unfortunately resulted in a bid to “ leapfrog ” access to interactive content. The end of apartheid. ( 9 ) held responsible for the of! Is evident that police officers involved in the back on that November day in 1990 around township! Africa in the struggle against apartheid. ( 12 ) black people in this country to be considered the... Gibson through Consultancy Africa Intelligence 's rights in Focus unit ( rights.focus @ consultancyafrica.com ) subscriptions our... Events hold great significance and are considered turning points in the 2011/12 reporting period alone is intolerable employees... Ipid said that it had managed to identify the duo who were oppressed become... ( rights.focus @ consultancyafrica.com ) brutality, stands by some sun flowers on a and.